This is the main conclusion of a new ICM-CSIC study published in Microbial Ecology, which shows that rising water temperatures combined with poor nutrition affect protists unevenly, favoring mixotrophic species.
Rising water temperatures and alterations in nutrient availability represent two of the greatest threats to marine ecosystems. However, previous scientific research had documented the effects of temperature increases or nutrient deficiencies in isolation, with the vast majority of studies focusing on analyzing a single stressor separately and under short-term exposures.
To overcome this limitation, a research team from the Institute of Marine Sciences (ICM-CSIC) has published a study in the high-impact journal Microbial Ecology that evaluates, for the first time, the combined effects of thermal stress and nutritional limitation on marine protists—the single-celled microorganisms that form the base of the marine food web.
The study was designed and carried out entirely at the ICM-CSIC facilities, where the scientific team analyzed how three protist species with different metabolic strategies respond when simultaneously subjected to scenarios of chronic warming (a sustained point increase of three degrees over years) or acute thermal stress (heatwaves), alongside diets deficient in nitrogen or phosphorus.
Unequal responses in plankton
Marine protists play a fundamental role in regulating the planet's biogeochemical cycles and transferring energy to higher trophic levels, such as fish and crustaceans. The study's results show that the consequences of thermal stress and nutrient limitation do not affect all species equally; rather, they depend heavily on their metabolic strategy and the duration of exposure.
"Traditionally, climate change models have evaluated environmental factors in isolation and assumed that stressors have similar impacts regardless of whether they are short- or long-term. In this work, we demonstrate the need to adopt a more integrative approach," explains Minerva García Martínez, lead author and ICM-CSIC researcher. "By combining temperature with the nutritional quality of prey across species with different strategies, we provide a more realistic view that allows for substantial improvements in predictions regarding the impact of climate change on the oceans."
To carry out the experiment, the team cultured prey in different media to offer protists a nutrient-rich meal, a nitrogen-limited one, or a phosphorus-deficient one. Subsequently, they measured how these combinations impacted their ingestion rates, growth capacity, and nutritional composition, among other parameters.
Advantage for mixotrophy
One of the main contributions of the study is the finding that mixotrophy—the ability to combine food ingestion with photosynthesis within a single organism—confers a clear tolerance advantage under various stressors. Under conditions of acute thermal stress (heatwaves) and phosphorus deficiency, mixotrophic species showed greater resilience and survival capacity compared to strictly heterotrophic protists, which rely solely on ingestion.
"This study demonstrates that global warming and nutrient limitation greatly alter the growth and nutritional quality of plankton. Given that they are the foundation of food webs, these effects could cascade down to the efficiency with which energy and nutrients flow to higher organisms, affecting overall ocean health," warns García Martínez.
After highlighting that certain groups of protists are more vulnerable than others to these disruptions, the ICM-CSIC team emphasizes the need for further research in this field.
"Looking to the future, new lines of research should focus on expanding the range of species studied to verify whether these patterns hold true in other natural communities. Furthermore, we will evaluate longer and more variable exposures alongside other environmental stressors to simulate marine ecosystem processes more accurately," concludes the researcher.